Does Guacamelee Deserve the Rating It Got?

Sometimes, big name game reviewers give games ratings they don’t deserve. Did they do this for Guacamelee?

After playing Guacamelee for hours, I believe Guacamelee is one of the great games of our times. It is one of the few co-op games I have played where the co-op can be played as part of the storyline, instead of after the game. I have been trying to find excellent co-op games to play with others, and have been unsuccessful until I found this game.

Guacamelee is also one of the most addictive games I have found; I can play the game for hours on end trying to perfect my moves, while still enjoying myself. The game received a 9.1/10 rating. I believe it deserves a perfect 10; it is an addictive game with an excellent co-op element. I am hoping that the developers behind Guacamelee create most great games, and especially more co-op games like Guacamelee.

Which games do you believe should have gotten a higher rating by big name reviewers?